The Goldfinch ~ Donna Tartt

The Goldfinch

Rating: 2/5

This book took me forever to read. If I had let the first half of the book get to me, I might not have finished it. However, that’s not to say I shouldn’t have put it down. After 33 hours on audio, I have finally finished this massive pointless tome.

I still feel nothing for the main character, Theo Decker. I began this book more than a year ago, put it down for almost a year, and finally decided to finish it to see if it lived up to the hype. It does not. Theo survives an accident that kills his mother in a museum as a child. He ends up with a painting of a goldfinch, that results in him becoming a part of the art underworld scene. However, in between, a lot of stuff goes down living with his father and spending time with his friend Boris.

Boris is quite the character, and perhaps my least favorite part of the story, although there are many least favorite parts. In the end, Boris’s main contribution is to philosophize on Theo’s life, adding in some optimism where there is none, and maybe shouldn’t be. He makes some decisions that initially end in Theo’s demise, but ultimately provide his salvation in a way that was not expected.

My favorite part of the book was Hobie, as he was a solid object for Theo. He provided stability and routine expectations, and unfortunately Theo took advantage of that. However, when Theo needed him, Hobie was there for him. Also in audio, the narrator’s voice seemed particularly suited for Hobie’s character.

I do have to hand it to this book, the story was all-consuming. I can see the appeal for some people, as the tragedy continues to escalate in a giant tragic spiral, but if you can’t relate to the characters, is it worth reading? I don’t think I really learned much about humanity through these characters either, although perhaps this appeals to middle class people not working with people whose lives are actually tragic in similar but much worse ways? I would still definitely recommend A Little Life if you need this itch scratched.

The writing was rather pretentious and over bearing, and I could not stand all the inane details. Where in A Little Life I couldn’t get enough of their every day lives and just wanted a few more words to draw out the story, in The Goldfinch I found myself counting down minutes, at times, laughing at the ridiculousness of the scenarios.

And the ending felt hokey, to cap it all off. I don’t want to read a book full of pessimism only to end in unreasonable amounts of optimism. I’m probably missing the point. Why did I spend 33 hours of my life listening to this book?

5 thoughts on “The Goldfinch ~ Donna Tartt

  1. “although there are many least favorite parts” – that made me laugh but yikes, never a good sign in a book! Thanks for sharing so much about this one, I’ve never read Donna Tartt but when I read fiction people were near insistent about recommending her books. Sounds like it was the right decision not to try them, I can tell I wouldn’t have liked this either 😳 hope your next read is much more to your liking!


  2. I was disappointed by this book and didn’t at all feel it lived up to the hype. The Secret History is one of my favorites, and a very different book. It might be pretentious at times, but a riveting story and one I’ve never forgotten.


Leave a Reply to showthisbooksomelove Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s